Skip to Main Content
It looks like you're using Internet Explorer 11 or older. This website works best with modern browsers such as the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, Safari, and Edge. If you continue with this browser, you may see unexpected results.

Writing Studies & Composition II - Spring, 2018: Home

Scholarly vs. Popular Materials

Element Scholarly Popular
Author Scholars with credentials in a specialized field Journalists, staff or freelance writers
Audience Scholars, experts, researchers, students of the discipline Members of the general public
Publication procedure Refereed; peer reviewed; juried; blind reviewed  Edited
Publisher Published by an organization or association in the field or a university Published by a commercial publisher
Frequency of publication Usually published three or four times a year More frequent—daily, weekly or monthly
Structure Title, abstract, introduction, review of literature, methods, findings, discussion, conclusion, notes, and bibliography/works cited Little or no citations; Format varies
Style Formal Varies—often conversational or entertaining
Support of argument Based on prior documented research (review of the literature) Confirmed sources; Opinion
Purpose To advance knowledge in the field To inform, persuade, or entertain; make profit
Scope Limited to field of study Often addresses broad interests
Appearance Plain, sometimes with graphs, tables, maps or photographs Glossy photos and advertising
Access Subscription only; May be available as open access material from scholarly/educational/research  organization/association/institution Subscription; Available for purchase at newsstands, bookstores, etc.

Communication Studies Reference Librarian

Hofstra University

This site is compliant with the W3C-WAI Web Content Accessibility Guidelines
HOFSTRA UNIVERSITY Hempstead, NY 11549-1000 (516) 463-6600 © 2000-2009 Hofstra University